Namely renaming and tweaking the `MsgType` receiving methods,
- `.recv_msg()` from what was `.recv_msg_w_pld()` which both receives
the IPC msg from the underlying `._rx_chan` and then decodes its
payload with `.decode_pld()`; it now also log reports on the different
"stage of SC dialog protocol" msg types via a `match/case`.
- a new `.recv_msg_nowait()` sync equivalent of ^ (*was*
`.recv_pld_nowait()`) who's use was the source of a recently
discovered bug where any final `Return.pld` is being
consumed-n-discarded by by `MsgStream.aclose()` depending on
ctx/stream teardown race conditions..
Also,
- remove all the "instance persistent" ipc-ctx attrs, specifically the
optional `_ipc`, `_ctx` and the `.wraps_ipc()` cm, since none of them
were ever really needed/used; all methods which require
a `Context/MsgStream` are explicitly always passed.
- update a buncha typing namely to use the more generic-styled
`PayloadT` over `Any` and obviously `MsgType[PayloadT]`.
Repairs a bug in `drain_to_final_msg()` where in the `Yield()` case
block we weren't guarding against the `ctx._stream is None` edge case
which should be treated a `continue`-draining (not a `break` or
attr-error!!) situation since the peer task maybe be continuing to send
`Yield` but has not yet sent an outcome msg (one of
`Return/Error/ContextCancelled`) to terminate the loop. Ensure we
explicitly warn about this case as well as `.cancel()` emit on a taskc.
Thanks again to @guille for discovering this!
Also add temporary `.info()`s around rxed `Return` msgs as part of
trying to debug a different bug discovered while updating the
context-semantics test suite (in a prior commit).
Since it should only be used from within a `Portal.open_context()`
scope, make sure the caller knows that!
Also don't hide the frame in tb if the immediate function errors..
By using our new `PldRx` design we can,
- pass through the pld-spec & a `dec_hook()` to our `MsgDec` which is
used to configure the underlying `.dec: msgspec.msgpack.Decoder`
- pass through a `enc_hook()` to `mk_codec()` and use it to conf the
equiv `MsgCodec.enc` such that sent msg-plds are converted prior
to transport.
The trick ended up being just to always union the `mk_dec()`
extension-types spec with the normaly with the `msgspec.Raw` pld-spec
such that the `dec_hook()` is only invoked for payload types tagged
by the encoder/sender side B)
A variety of impl tweaks to make it all happen as well as various
cleanups in the `.msg._codec` mod include,
- `mk_dec()` no defaul `spec` arg, better doc string, accept the new
`ext_types` arg, doing the union of that with `msgspec.Raw`.
- proto-ed a now unused `mk_boxed_ext_struct()` which will likely get
removed since it ended up that our `PayloadMsg` structs already cover
the ext-type-hook requirement that the decoder is passed
a `.type=msgspec.Struct` of some sort in order for `.dec_hook` to be
used.
- add a `unpack_spec_types()` util fn for getting the `set[Type]` from
from a `Union[Type]` annotation instance.
- mk the default `mk_codec(pc_pld_spec = Raw,)` since the `PldRx` design
was already passing/overriding it and it doesn't make much sense to
use `Any` anymore for the same reason; it will cause various `Context`
apis to now break.
|_ also accept a `enc_hook()` and `ext_types` which are used to maybe
config the `.msgpack.Encoder`
- generally tweak a bunch of comments-as-docs and todos namely the ones
that are completed after the pld-rx design was implemented.
Also,
- mask the non-functioning `'defstruct'` approach `inside
`.msg.types.mk_msg_spec()` to prep for its removal.
Adjust the test suite (rn called `test_caps_based_msging`),
- add a new suite `test_custom_extension_types` and move and
use the `enc/dec_nsp()` hooks to the mod level for its use.
- prolly planning to drop the `test_limit_msgspec` suite since it's
mostly replaced by the `test_pldrx_limiting` mod's version?
- originally was tweaking a bunch in `test_codec_hooks_mod` but likely
it will get mostly rewritten to be simpler and simply verify that
ext-typed fields can be used over IPC `Context`s between actors (as
originally intended for this sub-suite).
For comparing a `msgspec.Struct` against an input `dict` presumably to
be used as input for struct instantiation. The main diff with
`.__sub__()` is that non-existing fields on either are reported
(loudly).
Such that maybe we can eventually offer a nicer higher-level API which
implements much of the boilerplate required by `msgspec` (like
type-matched branching to serialization logic) via a type-table
interface or something?
Not sure if the idea is that useful so leaving it all as TODOs for now
obviously.
As in whenever `Context.cancel()` is not (runtime internally) called
(i.e. `._cancel_called` is not set), we can attempt to detect the parent
`trio` nursery/cancel-scope that is the source. Emit the report with
a `.cancel()` level and attempt to repr in "sclang" form as well as
unhide the stack frame for debug/traceback-in.
In the `drain_to_final_msg()` impl, since a stream terminating
gracefully requires this msg, there's really no reason to `log.cancel()`
about it; go `.runtime()` level instead since we're trying de-noise
under "normal operation".
Also,
- passthrough `hide_tb` to taskc-handler's `ctx.maybe_raise()` call.
- raise `MessagingError` for the `MsgType` unmatched `case _:`.
- detail the doc string motivation a little more.
In case the struct doesn't import a field type (which will cause the
`.pformat()` to raise) just report the issue and try to fall back to the
original `repr()` version.
Name them `_mk_send_mte()`/`_mk_recv_mte()` and change the runtime to
call each appropriately depending on location/usage.
Also add some dynamic call-frame "unhide" blocks such that when we
expect raised MTE from the aboves calls but we get a different
unexpected error from the runtime, we ensure the call stack downward is
shown in tbs/pdb.
|_ ideally in the longer run we come up with a fancier dynamic sys for
this, prolly something in `.devx._frame_stack`?
It ended up getting necessarily implemented as the `PldRx` though at
a different layer and won't be needed as part of `MsgCodec` most likely,
though this original idea did provide the source of inspiration for how
things work now!
Also Move the commented TODO proto for a codec hook factory from
`.types` to `._codec` where it prolly better fits and update some msg
related todo/questions.
Keep the old alias, but i think it's better form to use longer names for
internal public APIs and this name better reflects the functionality:
decoding and returning a `PayloadMsg.pld` field.
Allows passing a custom error msg other then the traceback-str over the
wire. Make `.tb_str` optional (in the blank `''` sense) since it's
treated that way thus far in `._exceptions.pack_error()`.
So when `is_started_send_side is True` we raise the newly created
`MsgTypeError` (MTE) directly instead of doing all the `Error`-msg pack
and unpack to raise stuff via `_raise_from_unexpected_msg()` since the
raise should happen send side anyway and so doesn't emulate any remote
fault like in a bad `Return` or `Started` without send-side pld-spec
validation.
Oh, and proxy-through the `hide_tb: bool` input from `.drain_to_final_msg()`
to `.recv_msg_w_pld()`.
Filling out the helper `validate_payload_msg()` staged in a prior commit
and adjusting all imports to match.
Also add a `raise_mte: bool` flag for potential usage where the caller
wants to handle the MTE instance themselves.
The `TypeAlias` for the msg type-group is now `MsgType` and any user
touching shuttle messages can now be typed as `PayloadMsg`.
Relatedly, add MTE specific `Error._bad_msg[_as_dict]` fields which are
handy for introspection of remote decode failures.
In the sense that we handle it as a special case that exposed
through to `RxPld.dec_msg()` with a new `is_started_send_side: bool`.
(Non-ideal) `Context.started()` impl deats:
- only do send-side pld-spec validation when a new `validate_pld_spec`
is set (by default it's not).
- call `self.pld_rx.dec_msg(is_started_send_side=True)` to validate the
payload field from the just codec-ed `Started` msg's `msg_bytes` by
passing the `roundtripped` msg (with it's `.pld: Raw`) directly.
- add a `hide_tb: bool` param and proxy it to the `.dec_msg()` call.
(Non-ideal) `PldRx.dec_msg()` impl deats:
- for now we're packing the MTE inside an `Error` via a manual call to
`pack_error()` and then setting that as the `msg` passed to
`_raise_from_unexpected_msg()` (though really we should just raise
inline?).
- manually set the `MsgTypeError._ipc_msg` to the above..
Other,
- more comprehensive `Context` type doc string.
- various `hide_tb: bool` kwarg additions through `._ops.PldRx` meths.
- proto a `.msg._ops.validate_payload_msg()` helper planned to get the
logic from this version of `.started()`'s send-side validation so as
to be useful more generally elsewhere.. (like for raising back
`Return` values on the child side?).
Warning: this commit may have been made out of order from required
changes to `._exceptions` which will come in a follow up!
Since the state mgmt becomes quite messy with multiple sub-tasks inside
an IPC ctx, AND bc generally speaking the payload-type-spec should map
1-to-1 with the `Context`, it doesn't make a lot of sense to be using
`ContextVar`s to modify the `Context.pld_rx: PldRx` instance.
Instead, always allocate a full instance inside `mk_context()` with the
default `.pld_rx: PldRx` set to use the `msg._ops._def_any_pldec: MsgDec`
In support, simplify the `.msg._ops` impl and APIs:
- drop `_ctxvar_PldRx`, `_def_pld_rx` and `current_pldrx()`.
- rename `PldRx._pldec` -> `._pld_dec`.
- rename the unused `PldRx.apply_to_ipc()` -> `.wraps_ipc()`.
- add a required `PldRx._ctx: Context` attr since it is needed
internally in some meths and each pld-rx now maps to a specific ctx.
- modify all recv methods to accept a `ipc: Context|MsgStream` (instead
of a `ctx` arg) since both have a ref to the same `._rx_chan` and there
are only a couple spots (in `.dec_msg()`) where we need the `ctx`
explicitly (which can now be easily accessed via a new `MsgStream.ctx`
property, see below).
- always show the `.dec_msg()` frame in tbs if there's a reference error
when calling `_raise_from_unexpected_msg()` in the fallthrough case.
- implement `limit_plds()` as light wrapper around getting the
`current_ipc_ctx()` and mutating its `MsgDec` via
`Context.pld_rx.limit_plds()`.
- add a `maybe_limit_plds()` which just provides an `@acm` equivalent of
`limit_plds()` handy for composing in a `async with ():` style block
(avoiding additional indent levels in the body of async funcs).
Obvi extend the `Context` and `MsgStream` interfaces as needed
to match the above:
- add a `Context.pld_rx` pub prop.
- new private refs to `Context._started_msg: Started` and
a `._started_pld` (mostly for internal debugging / testing / logging)
and set inside `.open_context()` immediately after the syncing phase.
- a `Context.has_outcome() -> bool:` predicate which can be used to more
easily determine if the ctx errored or has a final result.
- pub props for `MsgStream.ctx: Context` and `.chan: Channel` providing
full `ipc`-arg compat with the `PldRx` method signatures.
Since we need to allow it (at the least) inside
`drain_until_final_msg()` for handling stream-phase termination races
where we don't want to have to handle a raised error from something like
`Context.result()`. Expose the passthrough option via
a `passthrough_non_pld_msgs: bool` kwarg.
Add comprehensive comment to `current_pldrx()`.
Since we usually want them raised from some (internal) call to
`Context.maybe_raise()` and NOT directly from the drainage call, make it
possible via a new `raise_error: bool` to both `PldRx.recv_msg_w_pld()`
and `.dec_msg()`.
In support,
- rename `return_msg` -> `result_msg` since we expect to return
`Error`s.
- do a `result_msg` assign and `break` in the `case Error()`.
- add `**dec_msg_kwargs` passthrough for other `.dec_msg()` calling
methods.
Other,
- drop/aggregate todo-notes around the main loop's
`ctx._pld_rx.recv_msg_w_pld()` call.
- add (configurable) frame hiding to most payload receive meths.
Add new task-scope oriented `PldRx.pld_spec` management API similar to
`.msg._codec.limit_msg_spec()`, but obvi built to process and filter
`MsgType.pld` values.
New API related changes include:
- new per-task singleton getter `msg._ops.current_pldrx()` which
delivers the current (global) payload receiver via a new
`_ctxvar_PldRx: ContextVar` configured with a default
`_def_any_pldec: MsgDec[Any]` decoder.
- a `PldRx.limit_plds()` which sets the decoder (`.type` underneath)
for the specific payload rx instance.
- `.msg._ops.limit_plds()` which obtains the current task-scoped `PldRx`
and applies the pld spec via a new `PldRx.limit_plds()`.
- rename `PldRx._msgdec` -> `._pldec`.
- add `.pld_dec` as pub attr for -^
Unrelated adjustments:
- use `.msg.pretty_struct.pformat()` where handy.
- always pass `expect_msg: MsgType`.
- add a `case Stop()` to `PldRx.dec_msg()` which will `log.warning()`
when a stop is received by no stream was open on this receiving side
since we rarely want that to raise since it's prolly just a runtime
race or mistake in user code.
Other:
Basically exact same as that for `MsgCodec` with the `.spec` displayed
via a better (maybe multi-line) `.spec_str: str` generated from a common
new set of helper mod funcs factored out msg-codec meths:
- `mk_msgspec_table()` to gen a `MsgType` name -> msg table.
- `pformat_msgspec()` to `str`-ify said table values nicely.q
Also add a new `MsgCodec.msg_spec_str: str` prop which delegates to the
above for the same.
As per the reco:
https://jcristharif.com/msgspec/perf-tips.html#reusing-an-output-buffe
BUT, seems to cause this error in `pikerd`..
`BufferError: Existing exports of data: object cannot be re-sized`
Soo no idea? Maybe there's a tweak needed that we can glean from
tests/examples in the `msgspec` repo?
Disabling for now.
As per much tinkering, re-designs and preceding rubber-ducking via many
"commit msg novelas", **finally** this adds the (hopefully) final
missing layer for typed msg safety: `tractor.msg._ops.PldRx`
(or `PayloadReceiver`? haven't decided how verbose to go..)
Design justification summary:
------ - ------
- need a way to be as-close-as-possible to the `tractor`-application
such that when `MsgType.pld: PayloadT` validation takes place, it is
straightforward and obvious how user code can decide to handle any
resulting `MsgTypeError`.
- there should be a common and optional-yet-modular way to modify
**how** data delivered via IPC (possibly embedded as user defined,
type-constrained `.pld: msgspec.Struct`s) can be handled and processed
during fault conditions and/or IPC "msg attacks".
- support for nested type constraints within a `MsgType.pld` field
should be simple to define, implement and understand at runtime.
- a layer between the app-level IPC primitive APIs
(`Context`/`MsgStream`) and application-task code (consumer code of
those APIs) should be easily customized and prove-to-be-as-such
through demonstrably rigorous internal (sub-sys) use!
-> eg. via seemless runtime RPC eps support like `Actor.cancel()`
-> by correctly implementing our `.devx._debug.Lock` REPL TTY mgmt
dialog prot, via a dead simple payload-as-ctl-msg-spec.
There are some fairly detailed doc strings included so I won't duplicate
that content, the majority of the work here is actually somewhat of
a factoring of many similar blocks that are doing more or less the same
`msg = await Context._rx_chan.receive()` with boilerplate for
`Error`/`Stop` handling via `_raise_from_no_key_in_msg()`. The new
`PldRx` basically provides a shim layer for this common "receive msg,
decode its payload, yield it up to the consuming app task" by pairing
the RPC feeder mem-chan with a msg-payload decoder and expecting IPC API
internals to use **one** API instead of re-implementing the same pattern
all over the place XD
`PldRx` breakdown
------ - ------
- for now only expects a `._msgdec: MsgDec` which allows for
override-able `MsgType.pld` validation and most obviously used in
the impl of `.dec_msg()`, the decode message method.
- provides multiple mem-chan receive options including:
|_ `.recv_pld()` which does the e2e operation of receiving a payload
item.
|_ a sync `.recv_pld_nowait()` version.
|_ a `.recv_msg_w_pld()` which optionally allows retreiving both the
shuttling `MsgType` as well as it's `.pld` body for use cases where
info on both is important (eg. draining a `MsgStream`).
Dirty internal changeover/implementation deatz:
------ - ------
- obvi move over all the IPC "primitives" that previously had the duplicate recv-n-yield
logic:
- `MsgStream.receive[_nowait]()` delegating instead to the equivalent
`PldRx.recv_pld[_nowait]()`.
- add `Context._pld_rx: PldRx`, created and passed in by
`mk_context()`; use it for the `.started()` -> `first: Started`
retrieval inside `open_context_from_portal()`.
- all the relevant `Portal` invocation methods: `.result()`,
`.run_from_ns()`, `.run()`; also allows for dropping `_unwrap_msg()`
and `.Portal_return_once()` outright Bo
- rename `Context.ctx._recv_chan` -> `._rx_chan`.
- add detailed `Context._scope` info for logging whether or not it's
cancelled inside `_maybe_cancel_and_set_remote_error()`.
- move `._context._drain_to_final_msg()` -> `._ops.drain_to_final_msg()`
since it's really not necessarily ctx specific per say, and it does
kinda fit with "msg operations" more abstractly ;)
In prep for a "payload receiver" abstraction that will wrap
`MsgType.pld`-IO delivery from `Context` and `MsgStream`, adds a small
`msgspec.msgpack.Decoder` shim which delegates an API similar to
`MsgCodec` and is offered via a `.msg._codec.mk_dec()` factory.
Detalles:
- move over the TODOs/comments from `.msg.types.Start` to to
`MsgDec.spec` since it's probably the ideal spot to start thinking
about it from a consumer code PoV.
- move codec reversion assert and log emit into `finally:` block.
- flip default `.types._tractor_codec = mk_codec_ipc_pld(ipc_pld_spec=Raw)`
in prep for always doing payload-delayed decodes.
- make `MsgCodec._dec` private with public property getter.
- change `CancelAck` to NOT derive from `Return` so it's mutex in
`match/case:` handling.
Turns out we do want per-task inheritance particularly if there's to be
per `Context` dynamic mutation of the spec; we don't want mutation in
some task to affect any parent/global setting.
Turns out since we use a common "feeder task" in the rpc loop, we need to
offer a per `Context` payload decoder sys anyway in order to enable
per-task controls for inter-actor multi-task-ctx scenarios.
Sure makes console grokability a lot better by showing only the
customizeable fields.
Further, clean up `mk_codec()` a bunch by removing the `ipc_msg_spec`
param since we don't plan to support another msg-set (for now) which
allows cleaning out a buncha logic that was mostly just a source of
bugs..
Also,
- add temporary `log.info()` around codec application.
- throw in some sanity `assert`s to `limit_msg_spec()`.
- add but mask out the `extend_msg_spec()` idea since it seems `msgspec`
won't allow `Decoder.type` extensions when using a custom `dec_hook()`
for some extension type.. (not sure what approach to take here yet).
Handy for re-constructing a struct-`MsgType` from a `dict` decoded from
wire-bytes wherein the msg failed to decode normally due to a field type
error but you'd still like to show the "potential" msg in struct form,
say inside a `MsgTypeError`'s meta data.
Supporting deats:
- add a `.msg.types.from_dict_msg()` to implement it (the helper).
- also a `.msg.types._msg_table: dict[str, MsgType]` for supporting this
func ^ as well as providing just a general `MsgType`-by-`str`-name
lookup.
Unrelated:
- Drop commented idea for still supporting `dict`-msg set via
`enc/dec_hook()`s that would translate to/from `MsgType`s, but that
would require a duplicate impl in the runtime.. so eff that XD
Make a new `MsgType: TypeAlias` for the union of all msg types such that
it can be used in annots throughout the code base; just make
`.msg.__msg_spec__` delegate to it.
Add some new codec methods:
- `pld_spec_str`: for the `str`-casted value of the payload spec,
generally useful in logging content.
- `msg_spec_items()`: to render a `dict` of msg types to their
`str()`-casted values with support for singling out a specific
`MsgType`, type by input `msg` instance.
- `pformat_msg_spec()`: for rendering the (partial) `.msg_spec` as
a formatted `str` useful in logging.
Oh right, add a `Error._msg_dict: dict` in support of the previous
commit (for `MsgTypeError` packing as RAEs) such that our error msg type
can house a non-type-spec decoded wire-bytes for error
reporting/analysis purposes.
Mainly expanding out the runtime endpoints for cancellation to separate
cases and flattening them with the main RPC-request-invoke block, moving
the non-cancel runtime case (where we call `getattr(actor, funcname)`)
inside the main `Start` case (for now) which branches on `ns=="self"`.
Also, add a new IPC msg `class CancelAck(Return):` which is always
included in the default msg-spec such that runtime cancellation (and
eventually all) endpoints return that msg (instead of a `Return`) and
thus sidestep any currently applied `MsgCodec` such that the results
(`bool`s for most cancel methods) are never violating the current type
limit(s) on `Msg.pld`. To support this expose a new variable
`return_msg: Return|CancelAck` param from
`_invoke()`/`_invoke_non_context)()` and set it to `CancelAck` in the
appropriate endpoint case-blocks of the msg loop.
Clean out all the lingering legacy `chan.send(<dict-msg>)` commented
codez from the invoker funcs, with more cleaning likely to come B)