Doc the #477 migration outcome + one-shot-acm sketch

Fold the endeavour's resolution into the plan doc + log the
session per prompt-io policy,

- `ria_nursery_removal_plan.md`: RESOLVED section — migrate
  everything, remove the API; the migration-pattern table
  (blocking / fire-and-forget / fan-out / collect-don't-cancel
  / mutual-rendezvous), the semantic deltas (cancel-on-first +
  `collapse_eg()` chain collapse vs the old teardown-reap BEG),
  the excision inventory and the structural dissolution of the
  reap-hang class.
- adds the `to_actor.open_one_shot()` follow-up sketch: an
  `@acm` + private task-nursery over the existing blocking
  `run()` — done-`trio.Event` as a result memo (NOT a
  cancel-relay), no `Portal` in the iface, errors always
  propagate at scope exit; zero `_supervise` coupling.
- prompt-io entry `20260706T172818Z_ad42871e` (+ raw diff-ref
  companion) covering commits `d01a2123..ad42871e`.

(this patch was generated in some part by [`claude-code`][claude-code-gh])
[claude-code-gh]: https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code
drop_ria_nursery
Gud Boi 2026-07-06 14:31:34 -04:00
parent ad42871e47
commit c62f93a8fb
3 changed files with 209 additions and 4 deletions

View File

@ -367,9 +367,94 @@ user's failing-test-first convention). The poll-based reap
fix in `_supervise.py` is UNCOMMITTED and likely SUPERSEDED fix in `_supervise.py` is UNCOMMITTED and likely SUPERSEDED
by the re-scoping — do NOT land it as-is. by the re-scoping — do NOT land it as-is.
## RESOLVED (2026-07-06): migrate everything, remove the API
The PAUSED re-assessment concluded decisively: rather than
re-scope `_reap_ria_portals` (or bolt any hack onto it), the
`run_in_actor()` API itself was REMOVED — its non-blocking
"result at teardown" semantic predates streaming and confused
more than it served. Every in-repo caller was migrated
per-file/-group (each its own commit, each gated):
- tests: `test_infected_asyncio` `test_runtime` `test_rpc`
`test_spawning` `test_pubsub` `test_registrar`
`test_cancellation` (3 groups) `test_advanced_streaming`.
- examples: 4 non-debugging + all 8 `debugging/` REPL scripts
(debugger suite byte-identical green, 28p/6s).
- docs: 8 rst pages + the `experimental/_pubsub` docstring.
Migration patterns (the `run_in_actor` shape -> successor):
- blocking result -> `to_actor.run(fn, an=an, ...)`
- fire-&-forget/forever -> bg `to_actor.run()` task in a local
`trio` task-nursery (or `start_actor`
+ bg `Portal.run()` when a portal
handle is needed)
- concurrent fan-out -> N bg `to_actor.run()` tasks / or
`gather_contexts([p.open_context(..)])`
- reap-all-error-collect -> the "collect don't cancel" pattern:
each one-shot catches + stashes its
`RemoteActorError`, group raised
after the task-nursery joins (see
`examples/debugging/multi_subactors.py`)
- mutual-rendezvous -> peers must OUTLIVE both dialogs:
`start_actor()` daemons + concurrent
`Portal.run()`s + explicit
`an.cancel()` (eager one-shot reap
races the slower peer's dial of the
winner's dead sockaddr; found via
`test_trynamic_trio` flake).
Semantic deltas (tests loosened accordingly):
- teardown-reap-all BEG-of-N is GONE: local task-nurseries are
cancel-on-first, raced siblings' `Cancelled`s are absorbed,
and the runtime's `collapse_eg()` unwraps every single-member
group at each actor boundary — a fully-raced nested tree
relays a bare (annotated) `RemoteActorError` chain.
- `test_multierror_fast_nursery` deleted (pure reap-stress);
`test_nested_multierrors` re-purposed as deep-tree
cancel-cascade stress w/ a race-tolerant shape walk.
Final excision (after zero callers remained): `run_in_actor()`,
`._cancel_after_result_on_exit`, `_reap_ria_portals()`,
`Portal._submit_for_result/._expect_result_ctx/
.wait_for_result()/.result()`, `exhaust_portal()`,
`cancel_on_completion()`, `NoResult` — net -402 lines. The
reap-hang class (unbounded `wait_for_result` in machinery
scope) dissolves structurally: the only result-wait left lives
in the caller's task inside its own cancel-scope; the
`d1fb4a1a` anti-hang guard test passes by construction. The
poll-vs-`proc_waiter` debate is moot as predicted.
## Follow-up sketch: `to_actor.open_one_shot()` (run-async parity)
If deferred-result parity is ever wanted, the design that needs
NO runtime coupling, NO returned `Portal` and NO cancel-relay
`trio.Event` machinery:
async with to_actor.open_one_shot(
fn, an=an, **kws,
) as one_shot:
... # concurrent caller work
val = await one_shot.wait() # optional; errors always
# propagate at scope exit
an `@acm` that opens a private task-nursery, `start_soon`s ONE
task running the existing blocking `run()` and stashes the
value in a slot + sets a done-`trio.Event` (a memo, not a
cancel relay). Cancellation = plain scope-cancel of the acm's
nursery (the parked `Portal.run()` unwinds via `Cancelled`, the
shielded `cancel_actor()` reap still runs); a child error
raises into the acm scope so an un-`wait()`ed one-shot can
never silently drop its error. i.e. the old reaper's job is
done by scoping, not machinery. ~40 lines, all in
`to_actor/_api.py`, zero `_supervise` involvement.
## Verification gate ## Verification gate
- `tests/test_cancellation.py test_spawning.py test_local.py - per-migration-commit module gates on `trio` (+ `mp_spawn`
test_rpc.py` on `trio` + `mp_spawn` + `mp_forkserver` spot-gates incl. `test_infected_asyncio` per the B2 lesson);
backends, then full suite; `tests/devx/test_debugger.py` `tests/devx/test_debugger.py` for the REPL flows.
for risk 3. - full suite on `trio` + `mp_spawn` at branch tip + CI matrix
via draft PR #484.

View File

@ -0,0 +1,81 @@
---
model: claude-fable-5
service: claude
session: 6db64ac6-6986-4505-9343-df4ee31e67db
timestamp: 2026-07-06T17:28:18Z
git_ref: ad42871e
scope: code
substantive: true
raw_file: 20260706T172818Z_ad42871e_prompt_io.raw.md
---
## Prompt
Resuming the `drop_ria_nursery` (wkt) branch after the human's
review pause at `ba4af0ad`, with the directive:
> we need to resolve the remaining outstandings ... to finish
> this endeavour we ideally,
> - finish the ria-tn hoist into the machinery in `to_actor` if
> possible.
> - avoid supporting the `.run_in_actor()` non-blocking API
> going forward other then if we can re-wrap `to_actor.run()`
> per prior discussion with opus4.8.
> - get the test harness completely green locally and in CI -
> AND ESPECIALLY without any hangs due to the "the old
> spawn-backend reaper raced `soft_kill()`'s scope-cancel"
> - update all docs to reflect these changes once we're happy.
plus mid-flight additions:
> make sure both all the test and example code uses the naming
> `an: ActorNursery` for variable names
> where we at in terms of a potential hackaround design for
> supporting a to_actor.run_async() ... without requiring the
> same malarky ... with a `trio.Event` relay ... i'm totes fine
> with rejigging the iface to NOT return a Portal as well.
## Response summary
Completed the entire #477 `run_in_actor` removal on
`drop_ria_nursery` (16 commits this session), gated per-commit:
- ported the remaining `test_cancellation` groups
(`some_cancels_all`, `nested_multierrors`+`spawn_and_error`,
SIGINT + sync-sleep) — one-shots become concurrent
`to_actor.run()` tasks in local task-nurseries; BEG-shape
assertions loosened for cancel-on-first + the runtime's
`collapse_eg()` single-member unwrap (a fully-raced nested
tree relays a bare annotated `RemoteActorError` chain).
- fixed a pre-existing `UnboundLocalError` (`timeout` `match`
had no default arm for non-trio/MTF backends).
- ported `test_dynamic_pub_sub`, 4 non-debugging examples, all
8 `debugging/` examples (debugger suite byte-identical,
28p/6s; `multi_subactors` introduces the "collect don't
cancel" reap-all replacement pattern), 8 docs pages + the
`experimental/_pubsub` docstring.
- EXCISED the API + cluster: `run_in_actor`,
`_reap_ria_portals`, `_cancel_after_result_on_exit`,
`Portal._submit_for_result/_expect_result_ctx/
wait_for_result/result`, `exhaust_portal`,
`cancel_on_completion`, `NoResult` — net -402 lines. The
reap-hang class dissolves structurally (result-waits now only
in caller task-scope).
- found + fixed a real migration race: mutual-rendezvous peers
(`test_trynamic_trio`, `a_trynamic_first_scene.py`) flaked
because an eagerly-reaped one-shot dies while its peer still
dials the registry-resolved (dead) sockaddr — such peers now
pin lifetimes via `start_actor()` + concurrent `Portal.run()`
+ explicit `an.cancel()`.
- `an: ActorNursery` naming sweep across tests/examples (±82
lines, scoped renames, prose untouched).
- parked a `to_actor.open_one_shot()` design sketch (acm +
private task-nursery over blocking `run()`; done-Event as
memo not cancel-relay; no Portal) in the plan doc.
## Files changed
See commits `d01a2123..ad42871e` on `drop_ria_nursery`
(tests, examples, docs, `tractor/{runtime,spawn,to_actor,msg}`
+ `_exceptions/_context/experimental`).

View File

@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
---
model: claude-fable-5
service: claude
timestamp: 2026-07-06T17:28:18Z
git_ref: ad42871e
diff_cmd: git diff ba4af0ad..ad42871e
---
# Raw AI output (diff-ref mode)
This session's output spans the 16 migration/excision commits
`d01a2123..ad42871e` on `drop_ria_nursery`; per diff-ref mode
the verbatim content is reachable via the pointer below.
## Generated files
> `git diff ba4af0ad..ad42871e`
Commit-wise (each `Gate:`-footed msg documents its own module
gate):
- `d01a2123` port `test_some_cancels_all`
- `697c6152` fix unbound `timeout` (non-trio/MTF `match` arm)
- `fa8799d5` port `test_nested_multierrors`
- `f11754ce` port SIGINT + sync-sleep cancel tests
- `cb6202e3` port `test_dynamic_pub_sub`
- `d8af5f12` port non-debugging examples
- `a3057cb2` port debugging examples (+ `test_debugger`
nested-nurseries final-shape expectations)
- `d6bed7c4` port docs (8 rst pages)
- `07e1669e` fix stale `@pub` docstring example
- `2a59cefb` REMOVE `run_in_actor()` + the ria reap cluster
(net -402 lines)
- `a297a32a` fix mutual-rendezvous premature-reap race
- `ad42871e` `an: ActorNursery` naming sweep
Plan/design record updated in
`ai/conc-anal/ria_nursery_removal_plan.md` (RESOLVED section +
the `to_actor.open_one_shot()` follow-up sketch).